On Day 28 of Survivor Fan Characters 12: Fans vs. Canons. After the Immunity Challenge, Jeff announced that Maggie Greene would be receiving thirty-seven penalty votes to account for her several cases of intentional property damages, which was statistically enough to eliminate her from the game. However, Cleopatra Patterson pointed out that the idol had not been destroyed and was still in Enter's possession. It was then revealed that Maggie was really being ejected for physically assaulting Mike, requiring him to need stitches. Maggie then exchanged a few parting words with her fellow castaways before Jeff escorted her out.